Board Thread:Season Bidding/@comment-24103423-20130729053220/@comment-4190137-20130731085634

Ckarimalis wrote: In response to all the "Too soon" comments, I disagree. Revival was for people who didn't really get to play the first time (obvioulsy w/ a few exceptions) but I wouldn't say season 10 is too soon for an All Star season, considering season 8 was US survivor's first trademark All Star season. I don't think revival should count as an all star season, for those who played before and were eliminated before day 10, it was basically a first try.

I could also argue that US seasons 25, 26 and 27 all have returning players, two of which at least half the cast are returning players.

To support this argument further, the gap between Cuba and revival is 3 seasons, but gap between revival and s10 is 2 seasons,

...So for those who want to oppose on the arguement alone of being "too soon" I support you having an opinion, but I think your argument is invalid, and you really shouldn't consider being lawyers or anything. But that's enough of  what I have to think.

To Alfons. 24 is too many players? Really? That's only 2 more than revival, and no, season 10 was not anything special in US Survivor, but US Survivor's third season wasn't fans vs. favorites either, I don't think our wiki needs to adhere to US survivor standards, I think 10 is a perfect season for ALL STARS.

I think with Revival it typically didn't really involve stars of the game (except a few people of course), so I think having 22 was necessary (especially with the double boot on Day 1). And regarding the gap between Cuba and Revival, I would say back in Cuba we were too unintelligent to realise that we needed to have more newbie seasons, but now that we have identified that we shouldn't, I definitely don't think we should be cluttering the series with alumni seasons (such as the real show is doing right now). Anyhow I understand everything that you've said, and I think having an All-Stars season would be fantastic for Season 12 (even if it's 24 players I wouldn't be too concerned), sorry to kind of poop the party but this is just my opinion.