Board Thread:Season 51 - The Caribbean/@comment-37911756-20190225200030/@comment-4184065-20190226031618

Hey Jake!

I'm not upset that you are trying to win the game, all power to you on that front, but call a spade a spade and admit that is what you were doing in the first place, because you are admitting it now. Anyways, I did say in my last message I had realistic Plan B's. I had my idol for the final 6 if I lost, I think that is a pretty valid Plan B. Yousef brought himself to the final 5 with his idol, so I didn't have to work hard to get that to happen. I wouldn't have wanted Yousef gone at the final 6 even if he didn't have an idol, specifically for the reason you stated earlier about keeping threats. And going by this logic, you saying "it might have been a good idea to take you out before FIC" at the final 5, why are you advocating for me to have taken Elmo, when you are heavily implying that you would have taken me out over him anyways? So by your own logic, I actually DID end up making the right move about voting Elmo at 7, because you and Karsten (Karsten told me up front he wanted me out.) had no intention of keeping me at final 5/4, no matter if I made this move that you claim would be so good for me.

Also, to say that "I think it would have been an alright idea for you both to have at least considered" seems a little off to me. Do you think I just go with the first idea that pops into my head and don't think about other options? OF COURSE I considered keeping Elmo, and after thinking about it, I "considered" that the best move for me was to vote for Elmo at this spot. Which turned out to be accurate, because I wasn't going to make it through 5/4 without immunity, so to claim that I "needed all the plan B's" when you are saying none of them would have worked anyways, seems a little disingenuous. I was able to get my Plan A to work, I won the 2 immunity challenges I needed, Yousef was at the final 5 as a "Plan B". But if you're saying you still would have voted me anyways, then you don't have a leg to stand on about criticizing the correct move that I made, that got me to where I am now.