Board Thread:Season 12 - All-Stars/@comment-5051226-20140216193701/@comment-5051226-20140216215240

Well first of all, you weren't always honest with me: during the first vote, I told you immediately that I was voting for Taylor, you told me you were voting for him too, but ended up voting for me. I didn't talk to you much, but when I did, I did not lie to you. So when I made a deal with you, I was honest with you. My F3 plan was Gerda+Ben and it wasn't possible to get Gerda there at that point, so... That left an empty spot, so really it was up for you to grab. You chose to side with Gerda based on her reputation, instead of trusting our experience and the deal I made with you. So really, strategically, I'm not sure you considered every scenario as thoroughly as you're saying you did. The lesson here is this: assuming makes an ass out of you and me.

Secondly, I've been to ponderosa and something that I noticed is people were way more eager to vote for Gerda than for you... So even if your decision was strategic, I can't say it was your best move, because unfortunately, it doesn't matter what you know inside of your heart: what the Jury thinks is what matters. But I'll let you off this one because some Jurors have told me I'd win if I made the F3, so contrarily to what I thought at the time, you may have a better shot against Gerda than against me.

But what really seals your coffin as far as my vote goes is this:

SheerLoyd Manangan Moncatar i will agree not as a proposal but because i love you so much that even if it not might work, and me just agree with you all the time, i'll just set all my sadness aside.. but just so you know, i really want to punch andrei right now in the face for letting that PNG thing hit your mind.. however, i can't.. so i'll just do it

Even now, you're not being completely honest with me. That shows that your decision wasn't purely 100% strategic. It was emotional too, and you're trying to make it look a different way. So there is bullshit in your answer. Therefore, you can shove it back up your ass and come back to me when you're ready to be real with me.