Board Thread:Season Bidding/@comment-4379763-20131212064241/@comment-4190137-20131213065635

Tdemarest23 wrote: Okay, so I do like the idea on paper. Much like BvW which is kind of cool. The logo needs a bit of help. I'm not sure if it's something that Alfons made or not, but it seems to me to be a bit bland, and the writing a bit hard to read. Try to spruce it up a little bit. As far as the twists go, I HATE FIRST IMPRESSION VOTES. I think it's so unfair. I get it, Redemption Island stops that, but as you saw, Rupert and Candice did not make it far, and I think it's totally unfair to do that to anyone. I guess the two returnees are okay, only because it is Bailey and Will, but I kind of am not a fan of that because it's basically South Pacific 2.0. Idk, it's an interesting bid. I guess I'll just stay on this one. Good luck guys! A logo doesn't need to be extremely detailed for it to be good, and you can see the text from quite far out so I would say it's relatively easy to read (from someone who wears glasses looking at it without). But I do think there could be 1 or 2 things that could be added to make it better than it already is - like adding something relevant to the Tasmanian Aboriginal theme.

Normally First Impression votes come at an unexpected circumstance, but in this case it doesn't and only affects two people (Will and Bailey). Both of them signed up for this knowing they could be sent to Redemption Island on Day 1, therefore I don't believe it is quite as unfair as how a regular First Impressions vote would occur.

South Pacific wasn't predominantly bad JUST because of Coach and Ozzy, while those two are known to get on peoples' nerves it was mainly the aftermath of the first merged Tribal Council which shaped the whole entire season, that could happen in any scenario! Even if there aren't two returnees.